ISSN 2167-0404
International Journal of Medicine and Medical Sciences ISSN: 2167-0404 Vol. 2 (10), pp.197-203, October, 2012.© International Scholars Journals
Full Length Research Paper
An analysis of closed claims related to death in the Danish health care system
Lars Dahlgaard Hove1, Johannes Bock2, Jens Krogh Christoffersen2 and Hans Joergen Dam2
1Department of Anesthesia, Hvidovre Hospital, University of Copenhagen, Denmark.
2The Danish Patient Insurance Association, Copenhagen, Denmark.
*Corresponding author. E-mail: [email protected]
Received 22 July, 2012; Accepted 16 October, 2012
Abstract
Studies based on closed claims are important in our efforts to improve patient safety. The circumstances of the worst possible outcome of medical treatment: patient deaths from a complication to treatment were investigated. This retrospective study investigated closed claims concerned with medical-related deaths registered by the Danish Patient Insurance Association (DPIA). The present study used data from all reported complications from medical treatment in the primary health care and hospitals setting in Denmark. The results revealed from 1996 to 2008, 45,953 claims were made to the DPIA covering all medical specialties. Of these, 836 patients died as a result of treatment or lack of treatment. The total cost of the 836 claims was 40.0 million € corresponding to an average compensation of 59,300 € per approved case (range: 1,500 -1,200,000 €). The majority of deaths involved generally healthy patients. Almost every clinical speciality reported deaths as a result of an adverse event. Surgery accounted for the largest group of deaths, with 279 deaths occurring as a direct result of surgical treatment and 145 deaths caused by surgical treatment that came too late or no surgical treatment at all despite valid indications. Fifty-four patients died as a result of substandard treatment in primary care, and 782 patients died as a result of treatment at a hospital. Of the 836 submitted claims, 435 deaths were considered by the DPIA or the courts of law as a result of substandard care and considered preventable. This study thus gives an overview of the claims concerning deaths in the Danish healthcare system.
Key words: Closed claims, patient death, injury, malpractice, no-blame no-fault system and patient safety.