Advances in Experimental Agriculture

Advances in Experimental Agriculture ISSN 8931-3216 Vol. 1 (4), pp. 021-033, October, 2017. © International Scholars Journals 

Full Length Research Paper

A study to assess the profitability of growing improved maize OPVs compared with hybrids

*Oscar C. Gordimer, Steve Thabo Tambo and Jonty Gabriel Verwoerd

Department of Agriculture, University of Zululand, P. Bag X1001, KwaDlangezwa, 3886, South Africa.


Accepted 12 July, 2017


This study examined the profitability of growing Open Pollinated Varieties (OPVs) of maize against hybrids in the Eastern Cape Province, South Africa. Studies have shown that improved OPVs of maize can be a valuable step for smallholder farmers in semi-arid areas as they are relatively drought tolerant when compared to hybrids. Thirteen maize varieties were evaluated extensively by on-farm trials in selected areas under dry land and irrigated conditions. Nine were newly introduced and improved Open Pollinated Varieties (OPVs), while four were locally grown varieties. Among the locally grown varieties, one was a hybrid-check, while the remaining three were improved OPVs. The objective of this study was to assess the profitability of growing improved maize OPVs compared with hybrids. The Gross Margin analysis was employed to compute the gross margins of improved maize OPVs and hybrids. Results show that the hybrid PAN 6479 variety in general performed better than improved maize OPVs across all environments whereas in some areas, the improved maize OPVs had better gross margins and gross profit margins than the hybrid variety. The indicated genotypes however did not show specific adaptation to selected environments. From the results of the study, it could be put into perspective that it would be profitable to grow improved maize OPVs in the Eastern Cape Province by smallholder farmers given that the Province is semi-arid and farmers are resource-poor. On the other hand, hybrids require high-level use of inputs that could be costly for smallholder farmers.

Key words: Gross margins (GM), gross profit margins, hybrids, open pollinated varieties (OPVs), profitability, smallholder farmers.